
X and xAI dropped their Tribunal appeals and will train SA publishers for two years, but unlike Google's R688m deal, they commit no money to local media.
Elon Musk's X and the maker of Grok, xAI, have settled with the Competition Commission. South African news publishers will get workshops, onboarding help and training. They will not get money. The Commission announced the deal on Wednesday, 18 November. It closes the last open fight from its Media and Digital Platforms Market Inquiry.
X Corp signed a settlement agreement. SpaceX Super Intelligence, as xAI has been called since SpaceX bought it in February, gave a voluntary undertaking. Both had appealed the inquiry's remedies to the Competition Tribunal and have now withdrawn those appeals. In return, the Commission amended the remedies it imposed on X and withdrew the ones it imposed on xAI.
Google, by contrast, agreed in November 2025 to a support package worth R688 million, including R71 million a year for five years through Google News Showcase. X and xAI have committed no funds to South African media at all. The comparison is the Commission's own frame. One platform wrote a cheque. Two others wrote a training calendar.
The Commission's final report, released in November 2025, found that AI chatbots had used South African news content without agreement or compensation. X was the only platform that had not reached a deal before that report landed.
The report told X to make all its monetisation programmes available in South Africa, run twice-yearly workshops for publishers, and provide or fund digital literacy programmes, all for three years. It told xAI to train publishers on how to control the way its products use their content.
Those were remedies, not suggestions. X and xAI took them to the Tribunal. The settlement is what remains after the appeals were withdrawn. It is shorter, and it is thinner, than the report the Commission published a year ago.
X's commitments now run for two years instead of three. It must launch a monetisation support programme for publishers within six months of the deal taking effect. The deal takes effect once the Commission confirms the remedies have been amended. Until that confirmation, the six-month clock has not started, and publishers have nothing they can invoice or enrol in.
Publishers have to attend at least one of X's twice-yearly workshops and meet the platform's rules and integrity criteria before they get access. Where a publisher needs X's paid Premium tier to qualify for revenue sharing, X will provide it free for the two years. Earnings will be calculated the same way as for any other X creator. Workshops will be recorded and translated into up to five local languages where there is enough demand, and X will also run digital literacy programmes for adults and children.
"Access to revenue-generating tools, onboarding assistance, and training will help qualifying publishers build their revenue opportunities on X," the Commission said.
The sentence is careful. It says access will help publishers build opportunities. It does not say what a South African newsroom will earn, and X has not published the rate. Creator payouts on X are a share of whatever the platform already pays creators. A newsroom that clears the integrity test gets the same formula as any other creator. The Commission has not said how many South African publishers it expects to clear that test, or what "integrity criteria" means in a newsroom that publishes criticism of the platform's owner.
A free Premium subscription for two years is a real concession for a publisher that would otherwise have to pay to qualify. It is not a content licence. It does not pay for the journalism X's users already share, and it ends when the two years end.
The Grok maker's undertaking is narrower. For two years it will run twice-yearly training sessions on Grok's user settings and on robots.txt, the file websites use to tell crawlers which pages they may visit. The first session must start within six months of the Commission withdrawing the original remedies, and xAI will share its training material with X.
That training shows publishers how to opt out of future use. It does nothing about South African journalism already used to train Grok, or already used to answer questions in it. An opt-out that starts after the model has been built is a switch for the next crawl, not a payment for the last one. The Commission withdrew the remedies it had imposed on xAI. The undertaking that replaced them does not include compensation, and it does not include a right to see what Grok already holds.
Both deals cover South African print, online, radio and video news organisations that mainly report on current affairs or public-interest events, and that are current members of the Press Council or the Broadcasting Complaints Commission of South Africa. Outlets outside those two bodies are not covered.
That line draws a boundary through the local press. A newsroom that is not a member of either body does not get the workshops, the free Premium tier, or the Grok training, even if its work is already in the models. The Commission has not said how many member newsrooms there are, or what a non-member is supposed to do.
The inquiry's chair, Commission chief economist James Hodge, called the commitments a step towards turning the final report into practical benefits. Whether they become revenue depends on details neither company has published: how much a South African publisher can earn from X's creator payouts, how many local newsrooms will clear X's integrity criteria, and when the six-month clock starts. Until the Commission confirms the amended remedies, it has not started at all.
Google's R688 million is a number a publisher can argue about. This settlement is a calendar. Two years of workshops, a monetisation programme that has not launched, and training on how to refuse a crawler. The Tribunal appeals are gone. The money the final report was written to extract from these two companies is gone with them.
Source: SA Tech News




