
MPs heard SA law has no clear way to order pirate-site blocking. An adviser floated Icasa interim rules and an ECTA change; ISPA wants courts to decide.
Parliament's communications committee is considering whether to make internet service providers block pirate websites, and its own adviser says South African law does not currently give anyone a clear way to order that. Dr Jacob Medupe, content adviser to the Portfolio Committee on Communications and Digital Technologies, put a two-track plan to MPs this week.
The first track is an interim fix. The communications department and Icasa would look at regulations under their existing powers, to give internet providers guidance and legal cover for blocking illegal sites. The second is a change to the law, possibly a Committee Bill amending Chapter 11 of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act of 2002, the part that deals with service providers' liability.
For anyone with a fibre line or a mobile data contract, that would mean the company that sells the connection could be told to stop a customer reaching certain sites. The fight, as Medupe put it to the committee, is over who gets to give that order, and what happens when the order is wrong.
"The Act has no clear provision for court-ordered or regulator-directed website blocking," Medupe told the committee. That means there are also no procedural safeguards, no oversight and no appeal route built for it. The Act mainly protects service providers from liability for what passes over their networks. It was written so that a network is not treated as the publisher of every packet. It was not written as a switch a regulator can throw against a website.
The briefing found the other laws no better suited. The Copyright Act of 1978 has no mechanism to block infringing sites. The Cybercrimes Act creates no specific copyright piracy offence. The Films and Publications Act deals with classification and child protection. Much of the pirated content South Africans reach is hosted outside the country anyway, so a South African order has to land on the local provider, not on the server.
MPs heard that about 23 percent of South Africans use pirate sites, accounting for roughly 168 million visits a year. Neither account of the briefing gives a source for those figures. A committee that is being asked to change a statute, or to let a regulator write blocking rules, is being shown a scale of harm that nobody in the room has footnoted. Until someone produces the study, the 23 percent and the 168 million visits are claims, not a count.
The Internet Service Providers' Association accepts that access providers may have to block some illegal content. It wants a legal framework that respects the constitutional rights of South Africans, with blocking ordered by a court or a judge rather than by an administrative or regulatory body acting alone. The rules should be in legislation, the association says, with oversight, judicial review and public scrutiny.
That puts the industry against the interim track, which would rely on Icasa and the department rather than the courts. An interim rule can be written faster than a Committee Bill. It can also be written by the same institutions that would then enforce it, without a judge looking at the site, the evidence, or the innocent addresses that share the target's infrastructure.
The association also warned that every blocking method has a cost. Blocking domain names is the least disruptive for networks, and the easiest to get around: a new name, or a customer who types the address as a number, walks past it. Blocking IP addresses often hits innocent sites. The association pointed to a European court-ordered block that took down more than half a million unrelated websites. Deep packet inspection is expensive, slows networks, and can be bypassed with a virtual private network.
A virtual private network in that list matters. If the customer can leave the local network's view of the traffic, a block that depends on seeing the traffic fails for anyone willing to pay for the tunnel. The committee was not told how many South African subscribers already use one, or what a block is worth if the people it is aimed at are the ones most likely to route around it.
Medupe also asked whether blocking alone would work. He suggested pairing it with action against the commercial operators behind pirate services, cutting off their funding, better coordinated enforcement, and more affordable legal content. "The Committee could also ask whether blocking websites alone is enough to stop piracy," he said.
Committee chair Khusela Diko said the problem was more complicated than amending a law, and welcomed wider engagement with stakeholders. The committee's next steps are a legal opinion on whether current law already allows blocking within constitutional limits, consultations with industry, regulators and civil society, and a review of how the United Kingdom, Australia, Italy, Portugal and Canada handle it.
Neither account of the briefing mentions a draft bill or a timetable. The legal opinion has not been written, or at least has not been published. The consultations have not been dated. A Committee Bill amending Chapter 11 is a possibility Medupe put on the table, not a bill with a name and a clause.
Until that opinion lands, the position is the one Medupe stated. South African law has no clear provision for a court or a regulator to order a website blocked, and therefore no built-in appeal when a block takes down something it was not aimed at. The interim track would ask Icasa and the department to find a way anyway. The providers say that order should come from a judge. MPs have not chosen.
Source: SA Tech News




