
Operators' industry body ACT says ICASA's Home Affairs biometric SIM checks and five-number cap overlap with Rica. Comments close on 9 December.
The industry body for South Africa's mobile operators will not back ICASA's proposed biometric SIM checks and five-number cap in their current form. The Association of Comms and Technology (ACT), whose members include Vodacom, MTN, Telkom, Cell C, Rain and Liquid Intelligent Technologies, says the draft overlaps with Rica, the law that already governs SIM registration.
That matters to anyone who buys a prepaid SIM. ICASA's draft, published in Government Gazette 55631 on 28 October, would require operators to check a subscriber's fingerprint or face against Home Affairs records whenever a number is activated, re-activated or moved to a new SIM. Existing customers would have to be re-verified too. The operators who would have to run those checks now oppose the design.
SA Tech News reported the draft the day after it was gazetted. The proposal is a fifth amendment to the Numbering Plan Regulations. Written comments close on 9 December. ACT's answer, reported a day after that first story, is that the operators will not support the measures as they are drafted.
ACT's position was reported by TechCentral on 30 October. CEO Nomvuyiso Batyi separated support for the aims of the regulations from support for the measures themselves. "There are material differences between Icasa's proposals and the framework developed by industry," she said.
ACT's main objection is about which law applies. SIM registration falls under section 40 of Rica, which the Department of Justice administers. ICASA is instead using its powers over number allocation, through the Numbering Plan Regulations.
The distinction is not a wording quibble. Rica is the statute Parliament wrote for who may hold a SIM and how that person is identified. The numbering plan is the rulebook for how operators assign, recycle and manage numbers. ACT's case is that a verification duty of this size belongs in the first of those, and that putting it in the second creates a second compliance regime beside the one operators already run.
ICASA saw the point coming. Its explanatory memorandum says the new verification requirement "is distinct from the SIM registration requirement" under Rica. ACT's view is that two parallel regimes could duplicate implementation costs and disrupt the clean-up operators have already started.
That clean-up is the industry's interim framework, announced in June, which covers stronger identity checks, tighter registration controls and oversight of SIM distribution channels. ACT says it has sent proposals to reform section 40 to the Justice Department and is working with Home Affairs on technical standards for verification. On the Rica amendments, she said: "Every time it is updated and sent up the chain, it is turned back."
Those two tracks now sit next to each other. One is a draft regulation with a December comment deadline and rand penalties. The other is a set of proposals that, on Batyi's account, keep being sent back up the departmental chain. Operators are being asked to build toward a Home Affairs check while the statute that already covers registration is still being rewritten.
ICASA's memorandum counts 117,316,338 mobile subscriptions against a population of about 63 million, or 2.79 per person. When ICASA asked operators in 2025, most said they had already rolled out biometric verification, but only for post-paid customers. Prepaid users would be new to it.
The draft caps each subscriber at five mobile numbers per operator. Companies are exempt from the biometric checks but not from the cap. A business can skip the fingerprint or face match. It still cannot hold more than five numbers on one network under the cap as drafted.
The penalties are steep. Failing to verify a subscriber biometrically, approving a SIM swap for someone who doesn't match the records, or missing the re-verification of existing customers would cost R2 million to R4 million per contravention. Breaching the five-number cap, or skipping the identity check on a SIM swap, would cost R1 million per contravention.
The biometric, SIM-swap and five-number rules would only be enforced 12 months after the final regulations are published. Operators would then have two years to verify their existing subscribers against Home Affairs records. A subscriber who already has a working SIM is inside that second clock. So is a SIM swap. So is a number that is switched off and later switched back on.
Beyond the legal overlap, ACT says several matters need more work: the cost and technical feasibility of checks against Home Affairs, system integration, verification infrastructure, operational readiness and the effect on existing subscribers.
On the five-number cap, ACT points to legitimate multi-SIM use. Batyi said the limit "warrants careful consideration, particularly in light of South Africa's socioeconomic circumstances". The memorandum's own ratio, 2.79 subscriptions per person, is the figure the industry is being asked to reconcile with a hard cap of five numbers on each network.
ACT also objects to the pace. ICASA amended the same regulations in July, standardising how mobile numbers are recycled, and is now proposing a second round within four months. Operators would be implementing one numbering change while commenting on the next.
ICASA has not responded publicly to ACT's position. The draft does not say how many checks Home Affairs' systems can handle, what the checks would cost operators, or who pays.
The timing is also unclear. The draft says the amended regulations take effect on publication, but the biometric rules only 12 months later, and the two-year re-verification period runs from the date "of the Regulations coming into effect". It does not say which of those two dates starts the clock. A reader can treat publication as the start, or the later enforcement date. The text, as ACT reads it, does not settle that.
Written comments are due within 30 working days of the 28 October notice, which is 9 December 2026, by email to numberingresourceplancommittee@icasa.org.za. ACT says it will make formal representations.
Source: SA Tech News




